Which would you prefer?

Hey!

New here. I am trying to find somewhere where people can help me compare some trucks. I am trying to find something that I can use as my daily driver in the winter and a work truck in the summer. I work as a tree planter in British Columbia, Canada. So I do a lot of driving in the summers on logging roads sometimes carrying a quad, and usually 4-6 other planters plus their gear. In the winters I mostly just ski, so if the truck can handle my summer driving I am sure it will be able to handle winters in Canada skiing. I am currently comparing two trucks and I am not sure which suits my needs more. One is diesel which I like because then I have to fuel up less frequently (sometimes we do long drives 2hr+ and driving to town for fuel sucks) but I have been told they are just generally more reliable. The other is gas but is slightly smaller so possibly more fuel efficient. Anyways I'll post the links here and give me your honest opinions and we can discuss from there.

2010 Dodge Ram 2500

2014 GMC Sierra

Both are good trucks. Diesels can be more expensive to repair than a gas engine. The Ram mega cab has more room then the GMC. The fuel mileage may be quite similar between the two. I guess you need to decide if you really need a diesel truck

Generally speaking, (imo)from a cost to operate standpoint the gasser wins hands down. Just an oil change on a cummins is 130 plus. and what to do with 13 qts. of oil. Most people in the cold run gassers cause of the cold temps. Much easier to start and warm up faster. Diesels are not as bad as they used to be but..... . Happy hunting and remember, they are all man made. In other words, they are all junk. Its just a matter of whos junk you want to be seen riding (or pushing) around in. postcar.

Hey!

Both trucks can work for what you need, but here are some quick points:

Diesel (2010 Ram 2500): Better for long drives, towing, and heavy loads. Costs more to maintain. Fewer fuel stops.

Gas (2014 Sierra): Easier and cheaper to maintain. May use more fuel when hauling but better for short trips.

If you carry lots of gear and people, the diesel may handle it better. Before deciding, check the vehicle inspection report to see how each truck was cared for.

Want help comparing the reports?

Once again, 4 year old thread with the OP disappearing 1 day after asking his question never to be seen or heard from again. Very common on this forum, unfortunately.